Lenders have a very important factor to look at when they are processing your credit application and that is your credit report. Consumers need to have a record of making on-time payments on their current credit before they can get new credit. Thus, the credit history and the data credit bureaus such as Experian and Equifax gather and disseminate regarding your creditworthiness shape credit access directly. However, out of these three leading credit reporting agencies, which can provide more accurate and comprehensive data on your credit profile?
Experian and Equifax are two global credit reporting agencies.
TransUnion also faces competition nationally as a consumer credit reporting provider from Experian and Equifax. These credit bureaus compile information on consumer credit repute in the United States of America including loans, credit card payments, bankruptcies, collection data, and public records apart from other required credit information. The information is then put together to create easily comprehensible basic credit reports. The credit reports may then be purchased by other third parties such as creditors, landlords, insurance companies, and businesses because they assist in credit decisions.
Accuracy of Credit Information
As previously mentioned one of the crucial requirements of a credit bureau is to ensure credit reports are accurate and updated. You also need to be aware of how even small reporting errors can impact negatively your credit score and your chances of getting credit or loans. For the past few years, there has been research conducted to determine and compare the overall accuracy of credit reports from the three popular credit reporting agencies. The findings therefore indicate that as much as no agency is infallible, Experian does present slightly better record accuracy as compared to Equifax.
In a large meta-analysis conducted in 2004 that was financed by the U. S. Government Accountability Office, it was discovered that Experian credit reports were incorrect about 21% of the time. The degree of inaccuracy that Equifax reports however revealed was higher at 26 percent. This meant that approximately 25% of Equifax reports examined in the study had information that was potentially damaging to the consumers’ credit scores. Another study conducted by the FTC in 2013 revealed a slight enhancement across the industry, Nevertheless, Experian was still revealed to have fewer errors in the credit reports which normally varied between 11 to 14 percent contrast to 14 to 20 percent of Equifax reports which contained mistakes.
In addition to these multi-agency studies, it is also possible to compare figures of dispute process between Experian and Equifax which are also good for measuring general accuracy. That is why credit bureaus are obligated under the provisions of the Fair Credit Reporting Act to investigate disputed items on a consumer report and correct the mistakes if the consumer writes to the bureau arguing the mistakes as long as they are in the consumer report. As per the company reports, for the initial two quarters of 2022, Experian’s dispute resolution team handled more than 1. 5 million disputes and the firm’s average success ratio was calculated to be 96 percent. Equifax closed slightly less than one million disputes in the same period with a little over a 91 percent dispute resolution rate in terms of the volume of entries that were deleted or changed following disputes. The higher correction percentage indicates that Experian can eliminate errors and enhance its reporting as soon as it is aware of the differences.
Empirical Analysis of Completeness of Credit History Information
However, credit history depth is also important to maintain a good credit score, apart from correctness. Credit accounts and total positive months are revealed in the reports from Experian as well as Equifax and the more of them are visible for scoring models, the better picture of borrowing behaviors is painted. However, the two bureaus are not always accurate as one of them may times have a missing account history while the other may have incomplete data compared to the creditor.
As web-based consumer reviews and complaint sites indicate, Equifax, in particular, has more often failed to include whole trades in their credit reports – sometimes active accounts missing for several billing cycles or new accounts that were not reporting for three to six months after the account was opened. Because payment history is greater than one-third of the credit score formula, long-term gaps will significantly pull the scores down with Equifax in such cases. Most review sites show that the complaint about Experian not reporting open accounts or new trades is much less common as it does not happen in the first one to two reporting periods.
If you have reason to believe that Equifax or Experian is not reporting all of your key account history, then you will need to dispute that the information is missing and request that every active account be pulled. You can also try to discover trades’ reporting status by contacting your creditor directly to make sure that they report to both agencies.
Security and Consumer Protection
It is reasonable to assume that firms acting as custodians of sensitive financial data in the modern environment of cybercrime are expected to maintain reasonable protections for data. However, there is a major issue that Equifax faced a massive data breach in recent years which is considered one of the biggest in history and this has significantly impacted their position as a market frontrunner. Though it was leaked into the public domain in mid-2017, the company admitted that the hackers were able to penetrate the company’s systems and gain access to the sensitive data of almost 150 million Americans. The public nakedness of names, birth dates, addresses, driver’s licenses, and credit card details gave a significant blow to consumer and market confidence.
As we know, no database is safe from hack attacks, however, Experian has not witnessed any data breach that could come anywhere near Equifax’s calamity. Experian at the moment uses world-class means of data protection including sophisticated encryption, advanced malware software, multi-factor employee authentication, and other cyber security technology with highly-rated cyber protection systems. They have also adopted others such as blockchain technology recently to a greater extent in enhancing security in the authentication of the identity of the consumers when issuing reports. While the 2017 data breach was massive, Equifax’s dated network architecture and poor internal security policies were the reason for the failure.
Secondly, Experian’s identity protection provides better identity theft victim support and advanced cybersecurity measures. In the circumstance where you fall victim to fraud resulting from an extremely rare Experian system breach, you can enjoy details recovery services like an insurance policy, identity restoration support services, and a dedicated fraud resolution team. Equifax let down millions of affected consumers in the United States back in 2017, by firstly demanding the breach victims sign a non-legal case again It only emerged that they amended this requirement after a proper public uproar over the legal tactic.
Henceforth, we seek to answer one pivotal question: Which of the two credit bureaus is more reliable in general? Comparing the two credit bureaus, Experian does seem to come out as more accurate, complete, secure, and consumer-friendly as compared to Equifax. The small disparity in confirmed error rates, the enhanced account history submission, the prevention of data compromises, and advanced support for identity fraud put Experians as the dependability winner in credit reporting.
Nevertheless, note that when reviewing your applications, lenders make use of information from more than just Experian and Equifax credit bureaus. Thus, although there are differences between the two agencies if at least one of them returns a report that is flawless and does not contain omissions, this is enough for approval in some situations. This implies that one must monitor their credit score and credit reports with the three prominent credit bureaus at least once a year. Even if there are some inaccuracies listed in the Equifax report, correcting them immediately while having correct data in Experian and TransUnion can nonetheless beat occasional reporting discrepancies.
Call now for expert credit repair services: (888) 803-7889
Read More:
What is a good Equifax credit score?
Do lenders look at FICO or Equifax?
Does credit monitoring hurt your score?
